Follow foodtimeline on Twitter
Food Timeline FAQs: historic food prices

Average U.S. retail food prices (looking for other countries?)

[1600-1860]
The Value of a Dollar: Colonial Era to the Civil War, prices extracted from advertisements, newspapers, commodities listings, and personal inventories. Earliest prices are expressed in pence/colonial scrip. Food units are generally for large quantities, not comparable to modern supermarket prices.
[18th century]
Early American Tavern menu prices
[1720-1775]
Average wholesale prices of selected commodities in Philadelphia (bread, ship's bread, corn, rice, pork, flour, beef, salt, sugar, molasses, wine, & rum. Currency is expressed in Pennsylvania shillings. Monthly prices also available; 1762 sample. [SOURCE: Prices in Colonial Pennyslvania, Anne Bezanson, et al, University of Pennsylvania Press, 1935.]
[1786-1817]
Median annual prices for 14 leading commodities/Western Prices Before 1861/Thomas Senior Berry [Harvard University Press:Boston] 1943
[19th century]
American pioneer provision prices
[1817-1930]
Family food expenditures [1817, 1833, 1851, 1864, 1926, 1930], The American and His Food/ Richard Osborn Cummings
[1849]
Retail food costs, California gold miners
[1861-1865]
Civil war price fluxuations
[1860-2009]
The Value of A Dollar: Prices and Incomes in the United States, selected food prices extracted from advertisements and federal data [NOTE: Value of a Dollar books are available in most public libraries. In the back of this book you will find charts for selected items listing both historic prices and prices expressed in 2007 dollars.]
[1890-1970]
Basic commodities (go to page 31): average retail prices of eggs, bread, flour, milk, beef, potatoes, coffee, butter, bacon &c., reported by the federal government. Source: Historical Statistics of the United States: Colonial Times to 1970/U.S. Dept. of Commerce, volume 2, series E187-202. Retail food prices are supplied by the U.S. Dept. of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics. Source notes detailed on p. 11 of this document.
[1893]
Boston School Kitchen Text-Book/Mrs. D. A. Lincoln
[1900--present]
How much did food cost in Morris County, NJ? year-by-year; also cars, clothing, housing, furniture, recreation, etc.
[1902]
Sears Roebuck and Company Catalog, mail order groceries
[1911]
Thanksgiving food prices
[1913-1919]
Average retail food prices, Monthly Labor Review, July 1919
[1917]
Food for the Worker/Frances Stern & Gertrude Spitz
[1931]
Thanksgiving food prices
[1936]
Good Cooking Made Easy/Haseltine & Dow
[1961]
Thanksgiving food prices
[1980-present]
Average retail food prices --by product and region
[1981]
Thanksgiving food prices

Popular USA price surveys
Baseball stadiums
restaurant prices
Coca Cola vs. Pepsi
The "Hershey Bar Index"
Kellogg's Corn Flakes
lemons
McDonald's hamburgers
Nabisco's Oreos & Mallomars
Tea prices/American colonial, 19th century & 20th century/early

Additional considerations
The problem with comparing historic prices
Inflation calculators
Wartime prices


Inflation calculators
If a Reuben sandwich cost 35 cents in 1935, how much would that be in "today's" dollars?
You can use

Colonial American tavern prices
Colonial American tavern (publik house, ordinary) prices were set by law. Food was generally included with the price of room. Urban taverns offered a wider range of services, including both public and private dining facilties. These establishments offered meals to the general public. Menus were nonexistant; prices were fixed.
About colonial tavern foods.

Pricing notes here:

"The fare in a rural tavern...was simple, whatever the tavern keeper had on hand for his/her own family and was willing to share...The prices charged for food (and nearly everything else) in a licensed tavern were regulated by law. Tavern keepers were even required in some areas to distinguish between a "good" meal and a "common" one. However, whatever the quality of the food served, the proprietor was allowed to charge a predetermined price...On December 28, 1785, the day Thomas Allen...opened the doors to his new City Coffee House in New London, Connecticut, Allen recorded the prices he intended to charge his customers in...his day book. Breakfast, dinner, and supper were the same price, one shilling and six pence...At Allen, the meals were seldom as expensive as the drink sold...Dinners in many urban taverns were, following English custom, offered as "ordinarys"...meaning a prepared meal open to the public offered at an established time for a set rate...Dishes, in some cases, were passed communally and not available as individual portions...The Indian King in Philadelphia...offered "a regular ordinary every Day, of the very best provisions and well dressed at 12d a head...'...Congressman Samuel Read wrote his wife in 1775: We sit in Congress generally till half-past three o'clock, and once till five o'clock, and then I dine at City Tavern, where a few of us have established a table for each day in the week, save Saturday when there is a general dinner....A dinner is ordered for the number, eight, and whatever is deficient of that number is to be paid for at two shillings and six pence a head, and each that attends pays only the expense of the day."
---Early American Taverns: For the Entertainment of Friends and Strangers, Kym S. Rice for Fraunces Tavern Museum [Regnery Gateway:Chicago] 1983 (p. 85-93)

Sample New Jersey prices:

[1772:Mercer Country]
"Princeton, 30th September 1772, 60 Dinners @2 s(hillings) each"
---"History of the Nassau Inn at Princeton," Prof. V. Lansing Collins, Proceedings of the New Jersey Historical Society, New Series, January 1930, Volume XV, No. 1 (p. 52)

[1784:Burlington County NJ]
Breakfast, 1 shilling; breakfast extraordinary, 1 shilling 3 pence; Dinner, 1 shilling 3 pence; Dinner extraordinary, 2 shillings; Supper, 1 shilling; Supper extraordinary, 2 shillings."
---Old Inns and Taverns in West Jersey, Camden County Historical Society, 1962)

[1801:Middlesex County]
In May, 1801 [Vernon Tavern, New Brunswick NJ] prices were fixed by Council were for a good breakfast 40 cents, a good dinner 50 cents, a good supper 40 cents, lodging 12 cents, making $1.42 per day; while a common breakfast, dinner, and supper cost each 10 cents less or $1.12 per day, for the less particular customers. it would be interesting to know just in what the bill of fare differed.'"
---"Early Taverns in New Brunswick," Wm. H. Benedict, Proceedings of the New Jersey Historical Society, New Series 1918, Volume III, No. 3 (p. 137)

[1806: Salem County]
Best dinner with pint of good beer or cider 37.5 cents
Best breakfast, of tea, coffee or chocolate, loaf sugar 31 cents
Ditto of cold meat with a pint of good beer or cider 25cents
---Old Inns and Taverns in West Jersey

Alternative payment plans? Of course...
"In the course of examining the [Elizabethtown NJ] tavern ledger we find some unusual mediums of exchange accepted in lieu of money. Among those more frequently met with are labor, shoes, butter, provisions, wine--doubtless 'home brew'--bottles, hay and other commodities of nature. However, to find a plow credited to the account of John Meeker [1792]...is somewhat of a surprise."
---"An Elizabethtown Tavern and its Ledger," Elmer T. Hutchinson, Proceedings of the New Jersey Historical Society, New Series, October 1929, Vol. XIV, No. 4 (p. 453-454)

A note about wartime food prices:
Food in wartime is often a precious commodity. Prices are determined by availability and governmental regulation. In World War I our federal government established the
U.S. Food Administration, headed by Herbert Hoover.

During World War II the Office of Price Adminstration (1942-1945) set the prices of various consumer goods to stabilize the economy in the United States. Ration books were used to purchase many items. Most countries involved in WWII also rationed food and regulated prices. Dates, prices and food items varied according to availability. In Great Britain food rationing was the managed by the Ministry of Food. Cookbooks published during war years provide a wealth of information on prices, menus and rationing.

War ration book, New Jersey
Price and Supply on the Home Front, Harriet Elliott,Consumer Division, Office of Price Administration and Civilian Supply, Survey Graphic, July, 1941.

How can we find prices of popular items through the centuries to make comparison charts?
A "Food Thru the Ages " project sounds wonderful! Unfortunately, this is not a simple task. Determining accurate historic values of consumer goods is a complicated economic process--one which must factor in regional differences, inflation, labor costs and personal income. To make international comparisons one must also study the evolution of monetary systems and foreign exchange rates. This is why (for example) it is impossible to draw a simple chart of bread prices through the ages across all cultures. If you want to compare your local prices from one decade to another you will need to factor in the
Consumer Price Index for your area. Numbers are supplied by the U.S. Department of Labor.

About food prices & weights
Did you know that in Great Britain that a penny-loaf was set by law? Karen Hess, culinary historian, explained "Bread was the staff of life in Tudor and Stuart England, more so among the poor than the rich.... Its importance was such that the Assizes of Bread, dating from 1266, took upon itself overseeing and pricing of the bakers. The price of the loaf was fixed; the weight was permitted to fluctuate in compliance with an official table that took into account the price of wheat and the extent of bolting. The finest regular loaf was the penny white, next the penny wheaten...and the household penny 100% whole wheat..." (Martha Washington's Booke of Cookery, pps 17-18). You will find a link to the Assize of Bread and the Judgement of the Pillory (the punishment for breaking this law!) in the Food Timeline's teacher resources page, under the heading "laws".

If you want to make price comparisons in modern times you also have to pay close attention to changes in weights and measures. Package sizes/weights of popular consumer goods (candy bars, canned products, cereal boxes) vary greatly over the years.

Historic restaurant prices

Old menus are the best place to find historic restaurant prices. The challenge is to find ones from the type of restaurant you need (Steak house? Family-style chain? Roadside diner? Seaside lobster shack? Railroad dining car? World's Fair?) in the place/time you are studying. Case in point: Delmonicos 1830s menus. This is not an easy task. Very few old menus are uploaded to the Internet. Start here:

Delmonico's Bill of Fare, 1830s
How much did a meal in New York City's Delmonico's cost and what did they serve? Excellent questions. The
1834 Delmonico's menu (bill of fare or carte) was a simple list of basic items. Not quite the extensive gourmet fare history associates with this particular establishment. The best discussion of this first Bill of Fare is reported in "A Menu and A Mystery: The Case of the 1834 Delmonico Bill of Fare," Ellen F. Steinberg and Jack H. Prost, Gastronomica, Spring 2008 (p. 40-50).

Delmonico's 1838 menu was reprinted in the frontmatter of Lately Thomas' book Delmonico's: A Century of Splendor. This extensive menu reflects the gourmet glory of Delmonico's exquisite meals and wine service. Curiously? These menu prices were expressed in British currency. This stuns contemporary researchers expecting the new United States to eschew all things British. In context, it make perfect sense. We queried William Grimes, author of Appetite City about this phenomenon. He was kind to respond with this information: "The US used shillings and pence for quite some time, even after the revolution. Hence the cheap restaurants that served "shilling plates." The earliest Delmonico's menus reflect the period of transition from British-style coins to the US ones."

"Although French cuisine was gaining a foothold, the dominant cooking style in New York was still English, reflected in the profusion of oyster saloons and chophouses near the theaters, the markets and the centers of commerce...'Everything is done differently in New York form anywhere else....'...Any innovation that smoothed the flow was regarded as pure genius. Haly and Sabin's refectory on Nassau Street introduced the self-serve concept by arranging lighter dishes along a large table, allowing customers to pick and choose according to their pocket, their appetite, or their time. 'Here one can graduate his feeding precisely to his appetite, and can luxuriate from a penny's worth of bread and butter up to the full capcity of his purse.' the Tribune reported. 'Warm cakes morning, noon and night, good coffee, tea and chocolate, good steaks, etc. pies, cakes, etc. and one may fill with these for a New York shilling.'...For the present, New York's restaurants catered to every taste, at every price. In a fanciful sketch in the Broadway Journal in 1845, a 'gentleman in search of dinner' made a comic tour of the city's restaurants, driven from one dining spot to the next by a series of mishaps that whittled away at his bankroll of 'a half eagle and two shilling pieces.'...Reaching into his pocket to pay for an absinthe at the bar, the hapless gentleman realizes that one of the two shillings he gave the cabman was actually his half eagle. Suddenly, dinner at Delmonico's is off. He is now flat broke...Brooklynites who agreed paid a shilling at Bell's for roast meats (beef, lamb, veal or pork) or a shilling and a sixpence for roast fowl (chicken, goose, turkey, or duck)."
---Appetite City: A Culinary History of New York, William Grimes [North Point Press:New York] 2009 (p. 62-63, 71,72)

"The trend of the prices can be judged from two bills that have survived, rendered to 'J.O. Sargent' in 1840 and 1847, respectively...The 1840 bill was for four dinners (plus an incidental charge of 63 cents) at a total cost of $20.76. This works out to an average of about $5.00 per dinner...The 1847 bill was for six dinners, at a total charge of $55.50...The average cost for dinner this time was more than $9.00, though this increase might be attributed either to the fact that on two occasions, when the bill came to $17.88 and $12.00 respectively, Sargent entertained guests, or splurged on wines. The supplemental charges and costs of wines were what could run the check for a Delmonico repast up and up."
---Delmonico's: A Century of Splendor, Lately Thomas [Houghton Mifflin:Boston] 1967 (p. 45)

How much would these meals cost in today's dollars? Inflation calculators provide general numbers. What we don't know? What size were the portions and how many dishes, on average, were ordered.

Breakfast cereal: the Kellogg's Corn Flake study
Pioneering 19th century breakfast cereal manufacturers (Kelloggs, Post, Quaker, Ralston) left an indelible mark on American tables. In addition to filling generations of hungry bellies, breakfast cereals provide viable insight into our nation's economic situation. How? Prices and sizes of breakfast cereal products reflect dietary recommendations, agricultural surpluses, supply shortages, and political purpose. We selected Kellogg's Corn Flakes for our breakfast cereal price study because it has survived a century of changing consumer tastes, two World Wars, price fixing investigations, Stagflation and (now) Agflation. It's one of the few constants in a churning bowl of changing norms.

About Kellogg's: In the beginning, Kellogg's patented foods were served exclusively to the residents of the Battle Creek Sanitarium. According to the records of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office, Kellogg brand cereals were introduced to the American public May 1, 1907. A little taste of history. An interesting byproduct of this study was discovering the timeliness of Kellogg's advertising. In the earliest years, Kellogg's Corn Flakes were touted for their healthful properties as aids to digestion. During the Great Depression and WWII, Corn Flakes were promoted as meat fillers and milk extenders. In the 1950s and 1960s they were familiar, filling, and fun for afterschool and bedtime snacks. During the health-conscious 1970s these unpretentious flakes led the crusade. Ads laid low during the 1980s-1990s, when pre-sweetened cereals prolifertated. In the 2000s, as we warily watch American corn crops diverted to ethanol production, Kellogg's prices rise again. What story will these prices tell 10 years from now?

ABOUT THESE PRICES


About these notes: Food history can be a complicated topic. These notes are not meant to be a comprehensive treatment of the subject, but a summary of salient points supported with culinary evidence. If you need more information we suggest you start by asking your librarian to help you find the books and articles cited in these notes. Article databases are good for locating current recipes, consumer trends, and new products.
balloon pictureHave questions? Ask!

About culinary research & about copyright.
Research conducted by Lynne Olver, editor The Food Timeline. About this site.


http://www.foodtimeline.org/foodfaq5.html
© Lynne Olver 2000
9 December 2011